First things first kids - stop with the tears, GK's aren't the end-game for 40k. They all have force weapons, oh noes, world implodes.
Now that I'm past that bugbear, lets have a look at some misconceptions that I thought were obvious in the GK codex.
Lie Number 1: GK's all have power weapons, therefore are all assault troops of AWESOME!
Wrong. GK's do all have power weapons. That doesn't mean all GK's are dedicated assault units. GK's, in general, are NOT an assault army. DCA are about the only thing in the list that functions purely as an assault unit, with DK's a passable second. Paladins, Purifiers, Grey Knights, and the like, are NOT assault units.
Paladins are WS5, with 2 attacks, and 2 wounds, I hear you cry! They also only have a 5+ invo. Dedicated units of CC troops will still tear them to shreds, although wound abuse can do a passable job of keeping you alive. TH/SS terminators make you cry, as they do everyone else, in assaults. (But you are still better than they are, for other reasons. More on this later.)
Okay, what about Purifiers! Surely they are better, you can spam I6 halberds! No, still not an assault unit. They are still -just- marines. Torrenting or power weapons from invulnerable or fast troops still smash them. Sure, you can do some damage and smash units which can't beat Marines in combat but you're not a CC unit.
GKSS and Interceptors are not assault units either. They just aren't.
Get this into your heads people - you are a midfield DEFENSIVE army. You pack neither the bodies, nor the bonuses, nor the FNP, to roll through people in CC. Your sweet spot is 18+ inches away, and you want to shoot shoot shoot. Kirby and Stelek both have written lists that advocate this and you know what? They are fudgemuffining right. You WANT people to assault you. You want to have them run through terrain, or sanctuary (so tasty) or into your Counter Attack wielding units of GK's with force weapons. The longer you can keep shooting, the better off you will be.
Lie Number 2: Razorbacks are for hiding in, for scoring metal bawkses with psyheavybolters!
Guess what, they are. If you're crap henchmen, in a Coteaz list. For GK's? No. I've seen some advocating of this style of play and I commented on it in a previous post. The 1+1 concept works for GKS, BUT THEY ARE NOT BLOOD ANGELS OR SPACE WOLVES, OR MECH MARINES. These armies keep short ranged, single shot weaponry, inside the box, so that if someone does come close, you can counter it. Grey Knights keep 24" range, rending firepower, or infantry decimating firepower, in every unit (unless your doing some fluffy thing).
Simple steps for GK players, that should be the rule, not the exception. 1. Drive your razorback towards your midfield, and park it up sideways. 2. Pile your marines out, and put as many of them between each razor as possible, with the psycannons sticking out with clear LOS. 3. Either pop smoke, or open fire, dependant on how far you had to move. GK's do razormech by DOUBLING your fire power, not by hiding it inside boxes. By deploying out, you are providing your opponent with 2 targets, both of which are within threat range. Like any razor list, you will lose tanks/models. Unlike any other razor list, you don't have to be within 12" to make those foot units threatening to infantry.
Do. Not. Hide. In. Boxes. Your wasting 110 pts (minimum) of shooting power every turn, in an army that pays a premium for its units, based on their arms and armament. Note here though, when your units get whittled down, jump in the damn boxes. This is why I like to have some Rhinos available as well when I take large squads as if the psycannon still lives he can use that top hatch.
Lie Number 3: Draigo Lists are overpowered
They really aren't. They are 2 wound terminators. They die to torrenting, just like ANY other terminator unit. 5 Paladins still takes 10 unsaved wounds to kill. So does 10 TH/SS Termies. Deal.
Lie Number 4: GK's are newb friendly
They are not. They are as easy to pick up as any other PA army, just they cost more. Played against other newbs, with similarly newb armies, they will appear to be strong. Played by newbs vs intelligent, well skilled players, (our readers, I hope) they are JUST MARINES. Seriously people. Every tourney army is geared towards killing marines, or MEQ, as they will be over 50% of your opponents in most cases. Please stop freaking out about force weapon carrying dudes, its getting boring.
Truths, as Dan see's them.
The army is like the DE - best used in the hands of a veteran player. Units, much like the DE, can function in isolation, but do so averagely, and really need support. No melta pounces on the conviction that melta is required in 5th ed armies, and psycannons on every unit means midfield threat is amazing. You can do damage in assaults, but like the DE, it is basically an option to finish an already mauled unit, rather than what you should be aiming to do. Rifledreads are awesome, but hey, guess what, nothing new. They were still awesome at str7, just seems like everyone has forgotten that.
Grand strategy is nice, but isnt essential. It's best used on things like scouting units, or granting counter attack, or scoring dreadnoughts (yes, I know what the BRB says, about walkers, but any TO worth a damn can see that the GK codex states otherwise. Some may not, and they, are douchewipes.)
The scout shunt list is -OK-. Its not the end of the world. Competent players will still castle, and prevent you from getting a good first turn assault - they would do it with BA jumpers, or anything else that's going to assault them anyways. This is no different.
Librarians are amazing. So much utility, and not locked into abilities for a whole tourney, is grand. You do pay for it though, and an option for PA on these characters would have been nice (or artificer, even). 4 powers are must haves, in my opinion - Shrouding, Sanctuary, Might of titan, and WARP RIFT. Yes, rift. its 5 pts, for a guaranteed pen, at melta range. You pay more for a meltagun on a Grey Hunter, who can miss, and really needs to be 2" closer to guarantee a pen. Oh, and its a template, so ignores cover saves. Must have.
Coteaz is great, I just won't write a list for him. The other inq's are more like upgrades for units of GK's, rather than being real IC's on their own - rather, they are a cheap way to get rad nades, or similar, into a squad of paladins or the like, so they can lay the beat down a little harder.
They still aren't assault troops though.
So basically, that's that off my chest. Looking forward to getting more games in, and I'll probably not play my GK's in a tourney till much later in the year, say when another codex comes out, after the hype dies down.
Happy daemon hunting, you lot.
SneakyDan
Kirb your enthusiasm!
"...generalship should be informing list building." - Sir Biscuit

Friday, April 8, 2011
Comments (56)

Sort by: Date Rating Last Activity
Loading comments...
Post a new comment
Comments by IntenseDebate
Reply as a Guest, or login:
Go back
Connected as (Logout)
Not displayed publicly.
Connected as (Logout)
Not displayed publicly.
Posting anonymously.
Dan rants- Grey Knights, what they are, and what they aren't.
2011-04-08T03:37:00+10:00
SneakyDan
Analysis|Grey Knights|Nerdrage|SneakyDan|
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Nikephoros · 729 weeks ago
Since most armies are not comprised of those units, its safe to say that we need some perspective here.
Jalil · 729 weeks ago
Tier 1: TH/SS, Nobs, Genes
Tier 2: GK's, banshees, other" Reasonable" assault units
Tier 3: tacticals etc
tier 4: the rest.
Saramoff · 729 weeks ago
thornyroses · 729 weeks ago
abusepuppy 121p · 729 weeks ago
Now they are WS5 (so hitting on 3s like 'Stealers), rerolling wounds, and ignoring saves with every hit.
Yeah, they die to Fists, but 'Stealers die to torrent; every unit has its weaknesses.
(Warriors and 'Stealers kill approximately the same MEQs per point, incidentally.)
thornyroses · 729 weeks ago
Lackeylsk · 729 weeks ago
Warriors just need str 8 to get 1shot. Missle spam, powerfist, etc.
stealers are superior.
~Lackeylsk
abusepuppy 121p · 729 weeks ago
Warriors have three wounds to 'Stealers' one, so triple the cost is about right. (They have about the same killing power per point of cost, remember.)
4+ save means they don't get chewed to pieces trying to make that final charge. Lack of Fleet is unfortunate, but Infiltrate isn't a big deal- it just means they are arriving with the rest of your army rather than being a priority target early. You need to spend a couple turns cracking transports, anyways.
Yes, grab cover and hit the deck. If you built your army right, the Missiles aimed at your Warriors are ones that aren't going at your Tyrant, Tervigons, etc. Power Fists suck, but that's why you have Termagants.
Scott · 729 weeks ago
MathMan · 729 weeks ago
TH/SS Termies can't shoot. Genestealers can't shoot. Nobz... well, they're Orks. All GKs pack a potentially S5 Storm Bolter as a MINIMUM, and then can upgrade to better-than-assault-cannon special weapons. The power armor squads don't have to choose between heavy and special assault weapons -- psycannons are effectively carry both. The GKs are what Tac squads are supposed to be -- functional hybrids that can both shoot and fight with varying degrees of effectiveness.
Ever since I've seen the Codex it's been my opinion that people would freak out due to the force weapons, but the true power of the list would be in the mass of shooting (S5 Storm Bolters and psycannons).
Kirby 118p · 729 weeks ago
@Nike; real assault units really need to be able to do multiple things. Hit hard (high WS, number of A, strength), hit fast (high I) or taking a beating (good saves, invulnerables). Pick two. Paladins fit nicely into hitting hard (WS5, good number of A) but have to balance I and invulnerable saves (halberds v swords) but have a huge weakness to S8+ which in combat isn't all that uncommon. Everything else in the book generally doesn't have the hitting power (Purifiers are WS4) nor the durability to be a real combat unit and as MathMan said, are going to be shooting units first.
GKs are good in combat but are better at shooting and they have to cross a range (23"-6") where their firepower doesn't actually increase but other armies' do. As you get closer to most armies for example you get in range of rapid fire weapons for double taps and melta. GK are double tapping at 24" so have to cross that 'no man's land' for them to get to combat whilst many other armies will be crossing that distance regardless.
MathMan · 729 weeks ago
I suspect the difference in effective range is going to give the Knights a marked advantadge in ensuring they get to charge. Because the Knights fire at full effectiveness at 24", it will be the opponent who is forced to close the distance (they're not going to win a firefight trading bolter pot shots against S5 storm bolters). But once the enemy get within that magic 12", they get one salvo, because the Knights will be in assault range. Move up 6", unload their guns again, then lay into them with the Nemesis Force whatevers. Damned if you do, damned if you don't, essentially.
Kirby 118p · 729 weeks ago
This is what I think Dan means by defensive in this regards but also how GK are primarily a shooting force. They are better at combat than most generalists and some units like GKT, Paladins and Purifiers are pretty good, they just aren't OMGWTFBBQ amazing that many are making them out to be.
MathMan · 729 weeks ago
I guess my point is that the Grey Knights are more of a shooting-and-countercharge army rather than a purely shooty force a la Tau, but I guess we all agree on that and it's just about nomenclature at this point.
GKnewby · 729 weeks ago
MathMan · 729 weeks ago
The Meltagun has to roll to hit and pen first. It's got 1/2 odds of making a kill once it penetrates, but just hitting on a 3+ means that it would have a 33.3% chance of killing any tank... if meltas auto-penned. If you're shooting at a Land Raider, those odds of a kill are about 21% -- and I did factor in that you might kill it on a glance thanks to AP 1.
sirbiscuit 81p · 729 weeks ago
So odds are you only destroy the vehicle 1/6 of the time with Rift on a damage chart roll, a far cry from a meltagun's 1/2. While Warp Rift might be good for damaging tanks, it's hardly reliable at actually killing them.
MathMan · 729 weeks ago
Still, 15.3% chance of killing a Land Raider or Monolith, that's hardly terrible for five points.
MathMan · 729 weeks ago
I had noticed that and I was thinking "how much would I be willing to pay for a melta gun in that squad, anyway"? And for five points you get even better; it's almost an auto-pen (upwards of 90% when in range, just gotta make the Psychic Test) *and* it can kill infantry better. 1/3 chance of killing TH/SS Termies, for example, is better odds than what a meltagun shot will get before you even factor in that the template will let you hit more than one guy, and a similar calculation applies for Marines in cover. Heaven have mercy on low I stuff.
Warp Rift is brilliant. In an army with virtually no meltaguns, it's practically a no-brainer.
thornyroses · 729 weeks ago
Dalinair · 729 weeks ago
Not heard of giving them psy ammon to make them s8 then huh?
Xethik · 729 weeks ago
Citizensmith · 729 weeks ago
Xethik · 729 weeks ago
I see a lot of people taking the Grand Master when he only adds Grand Strategy to the army. Not worth 175 points alone. I wish this thought process was something all players realized. Good article.
MathMan · 729 weeks ago
Xethik · 729 weeks ago
It should have been: I see a lot of people taking the Grand Master when he only adds Grands Strategy to their army.
For example, mech-spammed lists with Coteaz and... a Grand Master. Just seems odd to me. Really, I think you'll want a Terminator unit or a decently large squad to put him in. Having a bunch of 5 man Power Armour squads doesn't really seem to gain much by putting the Grand Master in there, I feel like a Librarian or a Inquisitor would be better.
He is very good if he fits in the list.
Zjoekov 74p · 729 weeks ago
No wait...Warp rift! Meh, comparing it with a Meltagun is a bit 'no' as you aren't as mobile as, for example, a GH in a rhino. Nor do have multiple units which have this threat; making it easier to just avoid Warp Rift. Still a lot of potential though for 5 points heh.
SneakyDan · 729 weeks ago
Re rift vs melta - You are correct, no AP1 is somewhat of a hindrance, if you read this blog, i also advocated bloodstrike missiles because they are AP1. However, it still autohits, ignores cover (lol turboboosting eldar tanks) doesnt roll an extra dice for pen (lol monoliths, people still take them right?) and, if used correctly, can hit multiple vehicles, especially if someone is tank shocking you (which, with mech heavy armies vs foot/hybrid GK's, is gonna happen).
MOAR DISCUSSION! s'good.
TheWolfsLunch 61p · 729 weeks ago
Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, didn't really read the rule, this is just an assumption.
Victor · 677 weeks ago
Considering such a expensive model I'd just move apart from the tank rather than risking it to die, even if that model has a meltagun.
George · 729 weeks ago
Comrade · 729 weeks ago
I think, for the next week, the authors should just vent' in every post they do. Loosely warhammer related or not. Make outrageous claims, bag on their fellow gamers and just generally create a more negatively geared atmosphere.
Saramoff · 729 weeks ago
Really though, they're a midfield defensive shooty army? I hadn't thought of it like that, but what you say makes sense. Does this mean weapon upgrades on purifiers aren't worth it, or are they there to finish things? Hammers are still utility after all.
winter · 729 weeks ago
You want to shoot and shoot and shoot and then when you get assaulted smash as much face as you can before you die. The cheap upgrades on the Purifiers allow you to do this for minimal cost (on an 8 man squad the combat upgrades cost less than 10% of the squad for a significant upgrade in capability).
The easiest way to tell that GKs are not assault focused is the lack of decent ++ saves. The 5++ is not particularly good (and is on expensive models) and whilst you can get them to 4++ they are still not very good. Even if you go all out with a Brother-Captain with warding stave for 3 wound 2++ annoyance factor in CC, they still insta-gib to str 8.
Valtiel · 729 weeks ago
tzeentchling 76p · 729 weeks ago
Assume 5 GK Terminators with NFS (for a 4++) vs 5 TH/SS Termies. I don't know how the points work out, but assume for the moment that they are equal. WS5 S4 means out of 10 attacks, 3.33 wounds are caused, which means ~1.11 TH/SS terminator dies. In return, 1.66 GK Terminators die. Fairly equal, no? Half a terminator more kills on average. However, this doesn't take into account Hammerhand or any psychic powers the GK terminators may have - if Hammerhand is added in, that goes up to 1.85 TH/SS terminators killed, but Null Zone would bring the TH/SS terminators up to 2.5 kills.
As for survivability outside of combat, it would seem that the 3++ of the TH/SS terminators is superior; however, if the terminators can get any sort of cover (which is not too hard), the Shrouding makes their save just as good against 99% of weapons out there. Yes, it does require a)cover and b) a psychic power, but it is doable.
Then on top of them being nearly as good in both survivability and combat prowess, their shooting far outstrips TH/SS termies (by dint of their not having any). Quite frankly, I really don't think GK Terminators are as bad as people seem to be making them out to be, if supported correctly.
Tratchenberg · 729 weeks ago
And then not all the GK termies will have swords. The iniative bump from halberds is generally better as striking before units reduces the damage you take. At I4 you either strike after your opponent or you strike at the same time, either way you end up dead (or with enough casualties that you are no longer effective). So most terminator units are unlikely to have swords, maybe one to try save against token powerfist attacks. So more GK termies die to TH/SS termies if they want to be better against other things.
That said GK termies are probably the most effective unit against TH/SS termies in the codex (ignoring henchmen). Paladins go squish and nothing else has an invulnerable.
Desc440 · 729 weeks ago
I feel a little jealous of GKT, tbh. Vanilla termies (not assault termies) are pretty bad in comparison.
Archy · 729 weeks ago
But GK terms are WS4
winter · 729 weeks ago
The main issue is that they might end up being ok in combat, but they are still not a dedicated assault unit. "Supported correctly" they may be better than straight, but they still aren't a dedicated assault unit.
Desc440 · 729 weeks ago
Disagree. GK have the ability to play either way, as the situation dictates. The only thing they really can't do is hug the backfield due to lack of range.
Wyrmnax · 729 weeks ago
Desc440 · 729 weeks ago
makbeer · 729 weeks ago
Sethis · 729 weeks ago
Desc440 · 729 weeks ago
Sethis · 729 weeks ago
Desc440 · 729 weeks ago
tzeentchling 76p · 729 weeks ago
"Target unit now counts as a unit that may claim an objective."
These two statements are not incompatible.
abusepuppy 121p · 729 weeks ago
GK Libbies, like everyone else, have to pick their powers during army list creation, not battle-to-battle.
Very true about being a defensive army- but, of course, it's important to remember that having a defensive STRATEGY doesn't mean you always play defensively. There is a time to go for the throat.
RAW, Dreadnoughts don't score, but it was quite probably the intention that they be able to. We'll see, though.
blacksly · 729 weeks ago
CrusherJoe · 729 weeks ago
abusepuppy 121p · 729 weeks ago
soylent · 729 weeks ago
all that dakka, however, is worrying
Sneakydan · 729 weeks ago
That two powers for a tourney AP, rather than being locked into the same two for the whole tourney.
Re: psychic mastery three? Not worth the points, ever. 2 powers in your turn, and 2 in your opponents, should be plenty.
Re: scoring dreads- I know what the brb says, I states as much. I also stated that any TO worth a damn would rule in favour of it.
It's like BA Vindis not having templates. If you
Really thought that was how it was meant to work, your a douche :)
Sir_Prometheus · 727 weeks ago
I would say purifiers are assault troops, though. You'e paying 4(6) pts for something.....and it's not the ability to take two psycannons per 5 guys. It's for the extra attacks and cleansing flame.